Meaning & use
broken reed
Last updated
Meanings
nouncountableliterarydisapproving
A person or thing you relied on that turns out to be weak, unreliable, or unable to help.
Grammar: Countable and usually singular; it appears in the fixed phrase 'a broken reed' and often follows 'lean on' or 'rely on'.
Patterns
- a broken reed
- rely on someone as a broken reed
- lean on a broken reed
When the crisis came, the ally they had counted on proved a broken reed.
She thought the old committee would defend her, but it turned out to be a broken reed.
Do not lean on him; he is a broken reed in any emergency.
nouncountableliterarydisapproving
Something that gives no real help when you depend on it, such as a weak argument or a failing system.
Grammar: Used of things as well as people; the article 'a' is normal, and the plural 'broken reeds' is rare.
Patterns
- prove a broken reed
- turn out to be a broken reed
The report was a broken reed: it promised reform but offered no money.
Their backup plan proved a broken reed when the power failed.
Common combinations
- prove a broken reed
- The new law proved a broken reed, protecting nobody in practice.
- turn out to be a broken reed
- The promised funding turned out to be a broken reed.
- lean on a broken reed
- You are leaning on a broken reed if you trust that rumor.
- a broken reed in a crisis
- He is charming but a broken reed in a crisis.
Synonyms and how they differ
- liability
- Stronger and more neutral; it means someone or something that causes problems rather than simply failing to help.
- dead loss
- Informal British; it describes something completely useless, while 'broken reed' stresses disappointed trust.
- weak link
- Focuses on the weakest part of a group or chain, not on someone you personally depended on.
Opposites
Word family
- reed noun
- a tall thin grass that grows by water; the image behind the phrase, since a cracked reed snaps under weight.
Commonly confused: broken reed or broken record?
broken reed vs broken record
A 'broken record' is someone who repeats the same thing again and again; a 'broken reed' is something unreliable that lets you down.
Practice
The government promised support, but when the floods came that promise was ______.
Choose one answer.
'A broken reed' is the fixed singular phrase for something you depended on that fails you. 'A broken record' means repeated talk, and 'broken reeds' wrongly changes the fixed form.
Make it your own
Write a sentence using “broken reed”, then check it and compare it with the examples above.